I scored 27,000 elite correspondence draws under the tiebreak ICCF is voting on whether to trial. It finds a real signal in them, wrapped in a good deal of noise.
Wonderful analysis and findings. Also your proposal seems to have some merit. As a player who competes in these events regularly just at a lower rating band than the elite — I question whether playing under a system that dictates endgame material as an advantage when our modern engines deem it a draw. Wouldn’t any change towards such tiebreaks impact how each player then decides how to play the game moving forward knowing material advantage allows for a more favorable tiebreak for the results? I’m
on the fence as to whether or not making such a change that may impact a players decision how to proceed in a game is a good thing or bad thing. Curious arguments on either side.
What you raise is precisely the Goodhart question. It's hard to say for sure, but one would imagine people would start playing differently given new rules. So the association between pressing during the game and residual at the end of a drawn game may well disappear if people are forced to change how they play. But we won't know unless it's tried.
Great analysis. The problem I have with RTS is that I feel it makes a value judgment about play style. It seems that it penalizes dynamic play. Often the player that sacrifices material will have to settle for a draw in an ICCF game by repetition when their dynamic chances don’t materialize, or find themselves in a lost endgame. That is a valid outcome and it isn’t clear to me their effort to keep the game interesting should be penalized. My fear is this system will result in less dynamic and less interesting play and will heavily influence opening choices and variations played. What are your thoughts?
That is definitely the crux of the matter. I've tried not to go into this part of the argument in the piece as it is trying to be positive, while here we go into a normative discussion (fair give the proposal, as you rightly point out, is inherently normative in itself).
As far as my personal thoughts on this go, I did not enjoy playing in the predictive scoring tournament mainly due to the fact that I was no longer playing chess, and rather a puzzle to see which non-losing path is the least predictable for my moves and the most predictable for the opponent's moves.
RTS may be less offensive on that front than the predictive scoring, but it goes in the same direction.
Then again I do not necessarily have a better idea, but I think I'd still prefer the TCEC idea of unbalanced openings, which is also not ideal since you're not playing standard chess from the starting position, but it least down the line you are playing chess.
Wonderful analysis and findings. Also your proposal seems to have some merit. As a player who competes in these events regularly just at a lower rating band than the elite — I question whether playing under a system that dictates endgame material as an advantage when our modern engines deem it a draw. Wouldn’t any change towards such tiebreaks impact how each player then decides how to play the game moving forward knowing material advantage allows for a more favorable tiebreak for the results? I’m
on the fence as to whether or not making such a change that may impact a players decision how to proceed in a game is a good thing or bad thing. Curious arguments on either side.
Thank you, Nick!
What you raise is precisely the Goodhart question. It's hard to say for sure, but one would imagine people would start playing differently given new rules. So the association between pressing during the game and residual at the end of a drawn game may well disappear if people are forced to change how they play. But we won't know unless it's tried.
Great analysis. The problem I have with RTS is that I feel it makes a value judgment about play style. It seems that it penalizes dynamic play. Often the player that sacrifices material will have to settle for a draw in an ICCF game by repetition when their dynamic chances don’t materialize, or find themselves in a lost endgame. That is a valid outcome and it isn’t clear to me their effort to keep the game interesting should be penalized. My fear is this system will result in less dynamic and less interesting play and will heavily influence opening choices and variations played. What are your thoughts?
That is definitely the crux of the matter. I've tried not to go into this part of the argument in the piece as it is trying to be positive, while here we go into a normative discussion (fair give the proposal, as you rightly point out, is inherently normative in itself).
As far as my personal thoughts on this go, I did not enjoy playing in the predictive scoring tournament mainly due to the fact that I was no longer playing chess, and rather a puzzle to see which non-losing path is the least predictable for my moves and the most predictable for the opponent's moves.
RTS may be less offensive on that front than the predictive scoring, but it goes in the same direction.
Then again I do not necessarily have a better idea, but I think I'd still prefer the TCEC idea of unbalanced openings, which is also not ideal since you're not playing standard chess from the starting position, but it least down the line you are playing chess.
Agree with you - I also think TCEC style tournaments would be a welcome option. I don’t think RTS is appealing for all the reasons we discussed.