Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Matt Tedesco's avatar

Very interesting! But I do think that it might be excluding too many potential model games right now. I think that the assumption that only games that started two years prior count is likely to be problematic, particularly for modern engine era title matches. For example, in my database there are over 105,000 ICCF games played in 2025 and 2026 already in the database and close to 190,000 for 2024 on.

On the one hand I think it is underestimating ICCF model games that existed and on the other hand it is overestimating ICCF games that followed OTB model games. I think it would make sense that if the WC players and their teams looked at ICCF games, they would be looking at the most recent high-level games available. I think it is likely the assumption is discarding the games most likely to have been the ones that they actually referenced for modern (engine era) OTB title matches (the ones started most recently, within the two-year cutoff used in the analysis).

It would be interesting to get a report on how many games matched that were in that two-year period to better understand the scale of the issue. I think those would need to be checked manually by going through the archives to try to determine when they had been released. It is a shame that the completion dates are not recorded, which makes automating this very difficult if not impossible. This would likely only be possible for the ones that were played during the server era so that analysis would need to be limited to more recent WCs.

Ready for more?